BY: Lisa Esser-Weidenfeller | IN: Medical Malpractice
A growing number of rural hospitals — known as “critical-access hospitals” — are performing orthopedic surgeries, especially joint replacements. But because the staff at these hospitals is often inexperienced, patients who undergo surgery at these smaller facilities face a greater risk of complications, and even death.
Over the years, studies have shown that patients do better with surgery at a hospital that performs the procedure on a regular basis. Typically, this means larger, general hospitals and not rural hospitals.
When it comes to joint replacement surgery, the average rural hospital performed about 23 of the procedures in 2013. Meanwhile, general hospitals performed about 132 joint replacements during 2013. Hospitals that perform more than 100 joint replacements each year present the lowest risk of complications, according to reports.
A recent Wall Street Journal study (subscription required) of rural hospitals revealed that:
So why are rural hospitals performing more orthopedic surgeries? Various reasons have been given, including an increasing number of these hospitals merging with larger facilities.
But according to experts, the main reason for the increase is orthopedic surgeries is the financial incentives offered by Medicare.
Under a program implemented nearly 20 years ago, Medicare pays rural hospitals more than general hospitals for the same services, including surgeries. These higher payments were put in place to help ensure that rural hospitals stayed afloat and recovered more than their actual costs. Some in the health-care community are now suggesting these Medicare rules be changed.
Another distinction between rural and general hospitals is that critical-access facilities are not obligated to report their quality measures. This includes their rates of surgical complications. While some rural hospitals report this information voluntarily, most do not, giving would-be patients little chance of comparing their mortality rates with those at larger facilities.
View all posts byLisa Esser-Weidenfeller
Lisa Esser-Weidenfeller focuses her practice on medical malpractice, automobile negligence, and general negligence litigation on behalf injured plaintiffs.